In the wake of a nasty breakup, Emma (ANNIE MURPHY) spends the night with charming, much younger Luke (COOPER RAIFF), only to realize to her horror that she used to be his babysitter. As the pair stay in touch over the next few years, Emma makes some major life changes, including deciding to have the baby she’s always wanted. But when it comes to choosing a sperm donor, something about Luke makes Emma wonder if he might just be the perfect solution… in more ways than one.